The enumeration of chlorine-injured Escherichia coli and Enterococcus faecalis is enhanced under conditions where reactive oxygen species are neautralised

Aim: To investigate the effect of neutralization of reactive oxygen species (ROS-neutralized conditions) on the enumeration of chlorine-injured Escherichia coli and Enterococcus faecalis using selective and nonselective media. Methods: Pure cultures of E. coli NCTC8912 and Ent. faecalis NCTC775 were injured using dilute sodium hypochlorite, at free chlorine levels of 0.6 and 0.9 µg ml-1, respectively, and then enumerated at 37ºC by surface plate counts on nonselective nutrient (N) agar and on several selective media, either under (i) standard aerobic conditions; (ii) aerobic conditions using growth medium, supplemented with 0.05%-w/v sodium pyruvate, to neutralize peroxides; or (iii) conditions designed to neutralize ROS, using a combination of 0.05%-w/v sodium pyruvate in the growth medium, together with incubation in an anaerobic jar. Results: The counts obtained on the nonselective medium were lowest under aerobic conditions in unsupplemented medium, higher in pyruvate-supplemented (peroxide-neutralized) medium and highest for ROS-neutralized conditions. Counts for the selective media were often lower than those for nonselective N (nutrient) agar, with enhancement under peroxide-neutralized conditions and a further increase in counts under ROS-neutralized conditions. Broadly similar observations were made for three other strains of each organism. Conclusions: Chlorine-injured E. coli and Ent. faecalis become sensitive to ROS, giving higher counts under ROS-neutralized enumeration conditions than under conventional aerobic conditions. Significance and Impact of the Study: The enhancement in counts observed under ROS-neutralized conditions indicate that the addition of pyruvate to the growth medium may not fully counteract the effects of sublethal injury under aerobic conditions, which is a novel observation. Thus, ROS-neutralized conditions may be required for optimal enumeration of faecal indicator bacteria. Furthermore, the lower counts, obtained using selective media indicate that the sensitivity of chlorine-injured bacteria to selective agents is not necessarily reversed under ROS-neutralized conditions.